This is a facepalm moment. This is your incorrect assumption:
And you came to this assumption because you use similar OC settings for the two algos.
You can use the same OCs because the algos are similar, but you misunderstood this to mean the algos are similar because you can use the same OCs.
Ofcourse, you think OCs that are different by a few 100 Mhz resulting in a few percentage points difference in hashrate consitutes a large difference, so it makes sense that you are nitpicking.
It is clear we cannot learn from each other, so let’s stop trying.